You came this way: Home > jason > Blog > You(Tube) Can't Copyright a Bird Song / Public Domain Music From Christian Anarchists

jason (FMA Admin)

Mini Profile

REGISTERED:11/26/2008
COMMENTS POSTED:899
MIXES CREATED:114
AFFILIATIONS:---
jason on 02/27/2012 at 06:20PM

You(Tube) Can't Copyright a Bird Song / Public Domain Music From Christian Anarchists

Promo photo by Carina Romano

YouTube's Content ID system is a fascinating way for rightsholders to "block, monetize, or track viewing metrics." But it's far from perfect. The latest example is an incidental bird song that was falsely identified as copyrighted music. The result? Advertisements got slapped on the video, with revenue going to Google and the purported rightsholder.

The producer took to the web to explain that his nature video was shot "in remote wilderness away from any possible source of music." His slashdot post links to a related incident from 2009.

The 2009 copyfraud incident involved Psalters, a group of Christian anarchists who put all of their music into the public domain. Their music also happens to be quite good, and their 2004 album Us vs Us is now available on the Free Music Archive.

"A band dedicated to making music for God," Psalters are based in Philadelphia's enclave of radical Christianity. Their devotional music has an anti-establishment bent. Their website links to delassified CIA Records and Jesus Radicals alongside indie-pop gospeler Danielson's Sounds Familyre imprint, and they have shared the stage with similarly entrancing Saharan nomads Tinariwen. Psalters have a new album on the way, and details are available on their site accompanied by a full discography. Among psalters' other releases, live at 'Joe's Java' in Wilmington, OH. Currently, only the new album, "carry the bones", and "The Divine Liturgy of the Wretched Exiles" are available.

Share

User Comments

01
douglasawh on 03/15/12 at 02:27AM
the download does not appear to be working...
02
jason on 03/15/12 at 02:34AM
Hey Douglas. i just tried it and it worked. Are you seeing any sort of error so that we can troubleshoot?
03
douglasawh on 03/15/12 at 01:28PM
No errors, it just keeps being "interrupted." This is either the fourth or fifth attempt. I will try from a different location, but it is bizarre that it starts downloading but never finishes.
04
jason on 03/15/12 at 02:22PM
It sounds like your internet connection is getting interrupted before the download completes. Have you had this issue with other zipped albums? Hopefully it works alright from a different location.
05
douglasawh on 03/15/12 at 02:40PM
Jason, you know I've downloaded stuff from FMA before!

Good news is that it worked on campus.
06
douglasawh on 03/18/12 at 02:20AM
so, it's unclear what is going on, but something about Chromium is causing a problem. I tried to download another album today and had problems in Chromium. I then tried Firefox and it worked. I just figured I'd note the work around in case anyone else is having odd issues.
log in to post comments